HomeNewsWho We AreMissionMembershipEventsPhotosContact / Links
National Clergy Council
 
Pro-Life Leaders Argue For "Advance Directive" Law Reform
 

Read our past articles here!

From Our Members

Read articles from members of the NCC family

News Releases

Releases to the National Press

 

4/15/05

Burke Balch, Director of the Robert Powell Center for Medical Ethics, speaks to reporters at the National Press Club in Washington, D.C. on the efficacy of advance directives.

By: Dane Rose

WASHINGTON -- National pro-life leaders held a news conference today at the National Press Club on the importance and legality of advance medical directives, guidelines used to instruct medical professionals on how to treat incapacitated persons. Bobby Schindler, Jr., brother of Terri Schiavo, and members of the pro-life organization the National Right To Life Committee explained however, that even when an advance directive is present, laws in many states dictate that doctors do not always have to follow the signed mandates.

"Under the current law in most states, even if you clearly specify that you do not want to be starved to death, a doctor or a hospital doesn't have to give you the food and fluids that you've asked for." Mr. Schindler said. According to the NRLC, 41 states have laws "with no protection" or "questionable laws regarding continued treatment" of patients deemed to have a low "quality of life".

The NRLC is urging legislative reform in states that do not ensure advance directives will be followed. They have also begun the Will To Live Project, a national campaign urging people to declare their treatment arrangements in an advance directive.

The National Clergy Council, along with Faith and Action and the National Pro-Life Action Center, all of whom fought desperately with Bobby Schindler to save the life of Terri Schiavo last month, supports the NRLC and the Schindler family's efforts to protect the lives of the incapacitated. "The whole history of humanity demonstrates that there is nothing more evil and dangerous than when the powerful have control over the life and death of the weak. In Terri's case, her able-bodied husband, an authoritarian court, and an influential media ganged up on an innocent, disabled and dependant
woman. Any measure that would equalize the situation, and help restore the
right to live and be protected is welcome." NCC Chairman Dr. Paul Schenck said today.

"But we have to be careful, even in an advanced directive, we never have the moral right to determine the time or circumstance even of our own death, that is in God's hands. By the same token, we have to distinguish between killing someone, and letting them die in peace." he explained.

 

For more information on advanced directives, please visit the NRLC's website here.